Jalen Milroe entered the 2024 season as one of the most promising quarterback prospects, projected as a top-10 pick in the 2025 NFL Draft. However, his performance over the second half of the season has raised concerns, leading to questions about whether he should use his final year of college eligibility to improve his draft stock.
Milroe’s early season stats were impressive: 10 passing touchdowns, one interception, 954 passing yards, and eight rushing touchdowns in the first four games. But since then, his production has dropped significantly, with only five touchdowns, nine interceptions, and just one game exceeding 300 passing yards. Once viewed as a potential first-round pick, he has fallen out of that conversation, with some projections placing him as a late-round backup option.
Statistically, Milroe doesn’t stack up against recent first-round quarterbacks like Caleb Williams, Jayden Daniels, or Bo Nix. While his rushing ability is a unique asset, it hasn’t been enough to offset a decline in passing efficiency, evidenced by eight fewer touchdowns, four more interceptions, and a drop in passer rating from 172.2 to 153.8 compared to last year.
Milroe also faces the challenge of minimal improvement in key areas and the pressure of adapting to a new offensive system after a coaching change. Although some factors, like the loss of top weapons, may have affected his performance, his progression hasn’t matched expectations.
If Milroe chooses to stay in college, the question arises: should he remain at Alabama or transfer? Programs like Ohio State, USC, or Oregon, known for developing quarterbacks, could offer him a better chance to refine his skills. Leaving the SEC for a less defense-heavy conference might also bolster his stats.
Ultimately, Milroe must take the next step to prove he’s NFL-ready. One more year in college—whether at Alabama or elsewhere—may be the best path forward.
