Florida State’s 2024 season took an unexpected dive, finishing with a 2-10 record. Despite high expectations heading into the season, several transfers did not perform as anticipated. With hopes of bouncing back, the Seminoles have turned to the transfer portal once again, landing QB Thomas Castellanos, TE Markeston Douglas, and LB Stefon Thompson. Let’s break down how each of these transfers stacks up so far.
QB Thomas Castellanos – B
Castellanos, a dual-threat QB from Boston College, is a polarizing addition. Known for his strong rushing abilities, Castellanos struggled with accuracy but had a standout 2024 season with 18 touchdowns and five interceptions. His experience with Florida State’s new offensive coordinator Gus Malzahn is key, as he fits Malzahn’s spread option offense perfectly. If Castellanos improves his accuracy, this could turn into a standout acquisition for the Seminoles.
TE Markeston Douglas – C
Douglas returns to Florida State after a brief stint at Arizona State. Despite high hopes, his one-year absence saw limited success, recording just one reception with the Sun Devils. While he brings depth and familiarity to the tight end room, his impact remains uncertain. He might provide useful blocking in short-yardage situations but doesn’t significantly alter the tight end dynamic. Hence, a solid C grade for this move.
LB Stefon Thompson – C+
Thompson, a linebacker with a history at Syracuse and Nebraska, brings valuable experience in the 3-3-5 defensive scheme, which Florida State will now implement under defensive coordinator Tony White. After a stellar career with the Orange, his production dropped with Nebraska in 2024. While his fit with the new scheme is promising, it’s unclear if he’ll be a major upgrade over current roster options. His grade reflects potential, but not guaranteed success.
These early evaluations suggest that while none of the transfers has proven to be a game-changer yet, they each bring unique strengths that could help Florida State rebound in the 2025 season.
